Jim McElrath Sr.

Jim McElrath Sr.

Jim McElrath Sr.

Having a high school gymnasium named after you doesn't happen to just anyone.

To earn such an honor reflects the impact you've made on many people in a positive way throughout your lifetime. It also means you've earned tremendous respect and appreciation for your accomplishments.

Affectionately known as "Mac" by many in the community, McElrath enters the Hall of Fame for not only his many contributions as an administrator at JHS, but also his outstanding record as a basketball coach at Panama Central School, beginning more than 50 years ago.

Born in Oakmont, Pennsylvania, in 1935, he was an accomplished athlete himself, having played varsity basketball for Mercer High School, where he earned nine varsity letters, and at Westminster College and Grove City College before coming to Chautauqua County in 1957.

McElrath settled into the position of head basketball coach at Panama for the 1957-58 season and remained there through 1966. During his seven-plus years tenure, the Panthers posted a fine record of 115-31 and those wins included four sectional championships at Buffalo's Memorial Auditorium, And that was all before McElrath turned 30.

Jim McElrath Sr.

Jim McElrath and CSHoF president Randy Anderson at the rededication
of McElrath Gymnasium at Jamestown High School, December 14, 2013.

Before his arrival, Panama had never won a championship game and McElrath's teams created plenty of excitement for the village, bringing legions of fans to the PCS gym during basketball season and to the championships in Buffalo.

Don Wood, one of McElrath's former Panama players in 1962-63 offered this: "Coach McElrath had taught us not only to be winners playing his beloved game of basketball, but lessons that would be with us our whole lives."

Jim McElrath Sr.

1961 Panama Central School basketball Class C section 6 champions. Front row, left to right: Jon Rowe, Duane Faulkner, Bill Nordblum, Lee Hitchcock, Bruce Manwaring, Chuck MacDonnell Back row, left to right: Jim Sard, Paul Seekins, Claude Diemwe, Errol Swanson, Jim McElrath, Randy Otander, Ron Morse, Brady Fulmer, Tim Dalrymple

After leaving Panama, McElrath retired from coaching to pursue a career in administration, returning to college. He was an a ssistant principal at Cassadaga Valley Central School for a year and the principal at Jefferson Middle School for six years before heading to Jamestown High School, where he was named as principal in 1976. He remained there for 18 years until retirement.

During his time at JHS, his eye for coaching talent led him to bring Wally Huckno on board to coach the Red Raiders football team. McElrath and former JHS athletic director Komo Tane, another CSHoF inductee, also led the charge to bring Jamestown athletic teams into the Erie County Interscholastic Conference.

Jim McElrath is introduced by his son, Mike, for CSHoF induction

After his career at JHS came to a close, McElrath was elected to the school board, serving for three years and also was elected to the Jamestown City Council, where he served as an at-large member for eight years.

He also played an important role in developing and improving the athletic facilties at JHS, including the gymnasium that bears his name, thanks to a student-led effort to name the new building in honor of McElrath in 1994. His collaboration with the Chautauqua Striders also was critical to the creation of Strider Field.

McElrath was elected into to Mercer County Hall of Fame in 1994 and the Mercer High School Hall of Fame in 2002. He also was chairman of the scholarship committee for the Chautauqua Region Community Foundation for five years and was a task force member on the Chautauqua County Council on Alcoholism.

Jim McElrath Sr. was inducted into the Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame in 2012.

Jim McElrath Sr.

1959 Section 6 play-off program.

Join the Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame

A membership program is available to persons who are interested in preserving the history of sports in Chautauqua County and honoring the outstanding individuals who have created our cherished sports memories.

In addition to helping the CSHoF carry out its twin missions of maintaining a hall of fame and exhibit hall, members will receive several value-added benefits for their membership fee.

To join, please contact Russ Ecklund at
716-484-7684 or send an e-mail to


Inductees are honored at the hall in Jamestown, NY.


Take a Virtual Tour of the Hall of Fame!

order form

order form

order form

order form

Deppas Insurance
110 Mall Blvd.
Lakewood, NY 14750
Tel: (716) 763-4377

D & S Glass
333 Fluvanna Avenue
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 664-9321

G.A. Family Services
200 Gustavus Avenue
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 665-2116

Hope's Windows
84 Hopkins Avenue
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 665-5124

Lake Shore Paving
7 Osmer Street
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 664-4400

Legend Group
Lou Deppas, President
110 Mall Blvd.
Lakewood, NY 14750
Tel: (716) 763-9380

Lewis & Lewis
208 Pine Street
Jamestown, NY 14750
Tel: (716) 664-7354

Lind Funeral Home
805 West Third Street
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 664-3800

Shults Auto Group
300 Fluvanna Avenue
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 484-7151


Chautauqua Region Community Foundation
418 Spring Street
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 661-3390

Northern Chautauqua Community Foundation
212 Lake Shore Drive West
Dunkirk, NY 14048
Tel: (716) 366-4892


Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame
15 West Third Street,   Jamestown, New York 14701
© 2018 All rights reserved.

site designed and maintained by earth spark
image galleries powered by jAlbum