Jack Keeney

Jack Keeney

Jack Keeney

Pride Of Panthers
Remembering Keeney The Coach

The Post-Journal
By Scott Kindberg
March 12, 2013

When Ed Trisket, then a freshman, showed up for football practice at Panama Central School more than half a century ago, he was greeted by a new head coach, a 22-year-old by the name of John "Jack" Keeney.

Fresh out of Cortland College, Keeney wasn't much older than some of his players, which often made practice sessions quite interesting.

"The (coaches) were just big kids in '62,'" Trisket recalled in a phone conversation Monday night, "so they actually all decided they would scrimmage against us."

So Keeney and company pulled on the pads, snapped on the chin straps to their helmets and went toe to toe with the teenagers.

"We thought we'd get some licks against them," Trisket said, "but we were the ones who got licked."

What Trisket couldn't have known then, but certainly appreciates now is that the impact that Keeney left on him and countless others on the field behind the school 51 years ago actually has served as a metaphor for how to live one's life.

"He was almost like a father," the Niobe resident said.

On Thursday, the "father" of Panama football will be laid to rest, just weeks after being diagnosed with terminal cancer.

- - -

Deb Palmer first became acquainted with Keeney in 1977 in her first year as a teacher at Panama. "It goes without saying that our friendship was special," Palmer said. "To know the phone will never ring again for me to hear, 'Palmer, Keeney' pains me."

But what Palmer will be able to hold onto forever are the memories of a relationship that grew from Keeney as mentor and co-worker to Keeney as an abiding friend.

"We certainly solved a lot of problems over coffee over the years ... or at least we thought we did," Palmer said. "Our passion for Panama and the Yankees was our common thread."

And that friendship also included their respective spouses, Bill and Mary. Together, the couples took trips to New York City, Toronto, Cleveland, Buffalo and Philadelphia, almost always to see some kind of sporting event, most often involving the guys in pinstripes.

"Those were really great times with great memories," Palmer said.

- - -

Loren Smith was smitten by Keeney almost immediately upon meeting him nearly 30 years ago. Smith, now a teacher at Panama and a former assistant football coach, described his friend and mentor as an "innovator, a motivator and a captivator."

"At the end of the day (he taught me) that how you treat people and the relationship you have with other people is going to be your legacy,"

Smith said. "He treated people really, really well, whether they were athletes or bookworms in the classroom. He could find a way to get the most out of people around him."

Less than two weeks ago, Smith visited Keeney at the latter's West Ellicott home. During their conversation, Smith said the beloved coach didn't speak about his won-loss record, but rather about the relationships that his former players have forged and that endure to this day.

"He thought that they had bettered his life," Smith said, "but if you ask any (of his former players) they can't pinpoint one single thing that they did to make his life better. They'd say it was the other way around."

Chris Payne, the current Panama football coach, accompanied Smith on that visit. A Depew native, Payne arrived at Panama in 1995, wondering if he was "going to make it here."

Nearly 20 years later, Payne now "bleeds blue and white," thanks to Keeney's encouragement.

"I thank him for bringing me down here and believing in me," Payne said. "He's touched many lives and I'm just one small part of it."

- - -

Tim Card, Panama Class of '85, played for Keeney during a time when the Panthers made two appearances at the home of the Buffalo Bills, which was then known as Rich Stadium.

"He was an awesome coach and somebody I respected," said Card, now the highway superintendent in the Town of Harmony. "Sometimes you didn't always agree with him, but you knew he was right."

Take, for instance, the time in the mid-1990s when one of Smith's jayvee players had been ejected from a game for kicking a football in disgust after being flagged for repeated penalties.

"I went to Jack for advice," Smith recalled, "and he said, 'Maybe what you should do - because he didn't learn it the first time - is make him run 10 100-yard sprints, but make him kick the football down the field at the same time.'"

So every day for a week, the young man spent his post-practice time learning a lesson the hard way.

"Jack always had an edge about him that the average guy didn't," Smith said.

- - -

The first high school football game I ever covered was in 1984 at Panama. The Panthers were taking on rival Clymer. I don't remember how the game turned out, but I do remember the coaches - Keeney and Howard McMullin, the longtime Pirates' head man.

"I always looked at it as a real pleasure to coach against Jack," McMullin said, "because his teams were always well prepared and they always played with class. Jack was the same way. I really enjoyed it. Those were some fun times for us. ... We were right down the road from each other, which made it nice."

Dick Gallagher, the editor and publisher of Western New York High School Sports, remembered Keeney as a man who had a "passion for (football), a passion for the kids and was one of the most respected coaches and gentlemen I've ever encountered. He was always smiling."

- - -

Because of their shared passion for the Yankees, Palmer and Keeney would often exchange any book published about the franchise.

Last week, Keeney gave Palmer the latest Yogi Berra book - "Driving Mr. Yogi" - to devour.

"He handed it to me and said, 'Good book,'" Palmer said. 'I haven't read it. It's still sitting here.'"

I think it's fitting that the two longtime friends would share a book on Lawrence Peter Berra just days before Keeney's passing.

Known for his quotes, Berra once said, "You can observe a lot just by watching."

Wouldn't the world be a better place if we all took inventory of the things that we've watched Keeney do through the years and put them into practice in our own lives?

As Gallagher noted: "We need more Jack Keeneys on this earth."

- - -

A physical education teacher at Panama Central School for 34 years (1962-1996), Keeney was the Panthers' football coach for 33 years and athletic director for 30. In his time calling the shots from the sideline, he posted a 154-106-10 record, won four division titles and had four unbeaten seasons.

A former Section VI football chairman, Keeney also coached track and field, basketball, baseball, volleyball and swimming during his tenure at Panama. To honor his service, the athletic complex at the school was named the Jack Keeney Community Field in 1998.

Jack Keeney died in 2013. He was inducted into the Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame in 2015.

Join the Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame

A membership program is available to persons who are interested in preserving the history of sports in Chautauqua County and honoring the outstanding individuals who have created our cherished sports memories.

In addition to helping the CSHoF carry out its twin missions of maintaining a hall of fame and exhibit hall, members will receive several value-added benefits for their membership fee.

To join, please contact Russ Ecklund at
716-484-7684 or send an e-mail to


Inductees are honored at the hall in Jamestown, NY.

Submit a Nomination

You are invited to submit a nomination for induction into the CSHoF.

For induction into the Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame, the nominee must have been born in, lived in, or achieved in Chautauqua County, New York a name in the world of sports. He or she must also meet one of the following criteria:

  • Is or was an outstanding athlete in high school, college, amateur, or professional sports.
  • Is or was a coach, manager, official or administrator who has made a significant contribution to sports.
  • Is an individual who is performing or has performed an unusual or distinguished service in fostering, developing or effectively helping a sport to prosper.

Please visit our nominate page for more information.

Volunteers Needed

The Sports Hall of Fame is dependent on the volunteers who staff the hall. They are dedicated to the hall and the athletes honored there. The Board of Directors greatly appreciates the time and effort given by the volunteers.

The CSHoF can use additional volunteers to be at the hall during the day to greet visitors. To volunteer contact Randy Anderson at 716-640-6219.


Trophies on display at the Hall of Fame.


Take a Virtual Tour of the Hall of Fame!

order form

order form

order form

order form

Deppas Insurance
110 Mall Blvd.
Lakewood, NY 14750
Tel: (716) 763-4377

D & S Glass
333 Fluvanna Avenue
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 664-9321

G.A. Family Services
200 Gustavus Avenue
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 665-2116

Hope's Windows
84 Hopkins Avenue
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 665-5124

Lake Shore Paving
7 Osmer Street
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 664-4400

Legend Group
Lou Deppas, President
110 Mall Blvd.
Lakewood, NY 14750
Tel: (716) 763-9380

Lewis & Lewis
208 Pine Street
Jamestown, NY 14750
Tel: (716) 664-7354

Lind Funeral Home
805 West Third Street
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 664-3800

Shults Auto Group
300 Fluvanna Avenue
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 484-7151


Chautauqua Region Community Foundation
418 Spring Street
Jamestown, NY 14701
Tel: (716) 661-3390

Northern Chautauqua Community Foundation
212 Lake Shore Drive West
Dunkirk, NY 14048
Tel: (716) 366-4892

Hall of Fame
Joe AnnarellaJoe Annarella
Art AsquithArt Asquith
Harry BrosiusnHarry Brosius
Bob BrownBob Brown
Cal CederquistCal Cederquist
Paul CooleyPaul Cooley
Pete CriscionePete Criscione
Tom CusimanoTom Cusimano
Bill DavenportBill Davenport
Curt FischerCurt Fischer
Jim FotiJim Foti
Kay GouldKay Gould
Sheilah (Lingenfelter) GulasSheilah Gulas
Sam HammerstromSam Hammerstrom
Sheridan Hardenburg'Sherd' Hardenburg
Wally HucknoWally Huckno
Jack KeeneyJack Keeney
Charlie LaDucaCharlie LaDuca
Mel LewellenMel Lewellen
Francis 'Doc' Malinoski'Doc' Malinoski
Jim McElrathJim McElrath
Dennis MeszarosDennis Meszaros
Roger MooreRoger Moore
Bob MuscatoBob Muscato
Jolene NageloJolene Nagel
Flash OlsonFlash Olson
Deb PalmerDeb Palmer
Dave PolechettiDave Polechetti
Bill RaceBill Race
Terry RansburyTerry Ransbury
Joe SanfilippoJoe Sanfilippo
Bob SchmittBob Schmitt
Fran SirianniFran Sirianni
Al StuhlmillerAl Stuhlmiller
Mel SwansonMel Swanson
Walt ThurnauWalt Thurnau
Dale TillDale Till
Tara VanderveerTara Vanderveer
Jack WigleyJack Wigley


Chautauqua Sports Hall of Fame
15 West Third Street,   Jamestown, New York 14701
© 2018 All rights reserved.

site designed and maintained by earth spark
image galleries powered by jAlbum